Content warning: death.
In an article published on Stuff, Gavin Rose's mother wants him remembered as more than "the homeless drunk found dying in Napier's Clive Square". He died there in 2022, aged 32.
As a boy he knew every dinosaur there was, and his teachers called him the walking encyclopaedia. He was diagnosed with ADHD at primary school. At intermediate, his teachers suggested he might be Autistic. He was bullied for years.
From the age of 18, alcohol took hold. Over the next 14 years he moved between jobs, a charity flat in Hastings, backpackers, hospital, police cells, and short prison sentences for things like shoplifting and disorderly behaviour. After a cardiac arrest in a police cell, he lost some of his sight and was never quite the same. The coroner, whose findings were reported by Stuff in August, found he'd had significant input from various services but no "safety net" for the wider problems he and others like him faced.
Gavin died before police had the power to move people on. Since 25 October, they have. By early November they'd issued 29 orders, mostly for drunk and disorderly behaviour, police told RNZ.
That's the behaviour Gavin was in and out of trouble for. So the question the new law leaves open isn't abstract. When a neurodivergent or disabled person sleeping in a doorway is told to move, where are they meant to go?
Who is sleeping out there
The 2023 Census estimated that 414.5 in every 10,000 disabled people aged five and over were severely housing deprived. That’s more than double the rate for non-disabled people, 203.7 in every 10,000. For whānau hauā Māori the rate was 646.2, and for disabled Pacific people it was 987.0, according to Whaikaha's analysis of Stats NZ data.
Those figures don't only count people on the street. They include people in temporary accommodation, people staying in someone else's home, and people living in houses that aren't fit to live in. They can't tell us how many rough sleepers are disabled. They do tell us disabled people are far more likely to be without a safe home. We should expect them to be among the people facing move on orders.
There's also good reason to think we undercount. A 2021 review of 13 international studies by researchers Michael Brown and Edward McCann found homelessness services often struggle to recognise learning disability and the support that goes with it. If a service hasn't recognised it, a police officer on a night shift is unlikely to either.
It runs both ways
Disability makes it harder to find and keep a home. Homelessness also makes disability harder to live with. A 2023 report for the UK's Centre for Homelessness Impact found that being homeless can worsen existing conditions or bring on new ones. The researchers also described a catch-22 for neurodivergent people: support often depends on a diagnosis such as autism or ADHD, but getting a diagnosis without a fixed address is extremely hard.
The same report cites estimates that learning disability affects 13% of people who are homeless, compared with 2% of the general population, and that autism is heavily over-represented too. Those figures come from overseas studies, some small, and some count autistic traits rather than diagnoses. New Zealand has no equivalent figures, which is part of the problem.
Closer to home, AUT researchers Cordelia Stewart and Suzette Jackson interviewed 55 people experiencing homelessness in Auckland, including disabled and neurodivergent people. They found no clear way into the system. People in crisis were expected to find the right services, work out whether they qualified, and coordinate their own support. Many services ran through online portals and phones that people didn't have, and staff turnover meant retelling traumatic stories again and again.
For someone with a learning disability, a brain injury, or a communication impairment, that's a system built around the very skills their impairment affects.
What the law enables
The law that passed in September is narrower than the Bill first introduced. It now applies only to adults. A person moved on for rough sleeping can come back to the area, as long as they don't do any of the behaviours the law prohibits.
Police say officers will take a graduated approach: talk to the person first, explain why the behaviour is a concern, and encourage them to move voluntarily. An order is a last step. Police have also said they'll monitor how the powers are used. When the law passed, the Justice Minister said move-on orders "do not criminalise homelessness" and that only people who refuse an order will face prosecution.
All of that matters. The problem is, every one of those safeguards assumes the person has somewhere else to be.
Where the system sends people
The Government's own homelessness report, covering the year to September 2025, is blunt. Council staff told the Ministry of Housing and Urban Development there is a lack of suitable housing and support, "especially for disabled people and those with complex needs".
People working in the sector reported that many are forced to decline shared temporary accommodation because of their support or health needs. Often the bed is in a shared space they physically can't use, or can't live in without the support they rely on. UK researchers heard from an autistic woman who was told shared accommodation was her only option, when living with several strangers simply wasn't possible for her.
In April, CCS Disability Action's Operations Manager Bettina Syme made the same point about emergency housing. A wheelchair user who relies on an accessible bathroom, local support, and nearby health services can't simply move at short notice into a motel on the other side of town.
The social housing register adds another trap. MSD's rules say a person who turns down a suitable property without a good and sufficient reason may be removed from the register. Whether a house is "suitable" for a disabled person depends on access details the offer may not capture. Our April piece described a disabled colleague being removed from the register twice, the first time without being told.
So if shared accommodation doesn't fit, emergency housing isn’t accessible, and a register can count a "no" against you – where does that leave you? A move-on order doesn't change any of that.
Being told vs. understanding
The law says an order must be given in writing or electronically. Think about who that works for.
Picture a written order handed to someone with a learning disability, a Deaf person who uses NZSL, or someone with a brain injury. Handing it over doesn't tell us whether they understood what they were asked to do, how far to go, or for how long. Refusing an order is what leads to prosecution. Not understanding one can look exactly the same from the outside.
Police's graduated approach is the right place to fix this. Explaining and encouraging only works if the explanation lands.
What should happen now
This means we need agencies to act on what they already know.
Police should record when an order involves a person with an apparent disability or access need, and report it alongside the other figures they're monitoring. If disabled people are being moved on, we need to know.
Police should have accessible ways to explain an order, including Easy Read and NZSL, and a way to check the person understood, before anyone can be said to have refused.
Every order for rough sleeping should come with a real referral to outreach or housing support, so being moved on is also a way in.
And MSD, the Ministry of Housing and Urban Development, and Kāinga Ora should stop treating a disabled person's "no" to unsuitable housing as a choice. We asked in April for outcomes for disabled applicants who decline unsuitable offers to be tracked. That's more urgent now.
Whoever forms the next government will inherit this law. Before anyone measures its success by how few people are seen in doorways, they should be able to say where those disabled people went.
